How to Integrate Custom Payment Gateways in Shopify (2025)

Do not index

OG Image

Status

In Progress

Type

Blog Post

What Are Custom Payment Gateways and Why Do You Need One?

Picture this: you've built a successful e-commerce business, but your customers keep abandoning their carts at checkout because their preferred payment method isn't available.

Maybe you're targeting customers in Southeast Asia who prefer local bank transfers. Or you need crypto payments for your tech-savvy audience. This is where custom payment gateways come in.

A custom payment gateway is your direct line to specialized payment methods that Shopify doesn't offer out of the box.

Instead of forcing customers to adapt to limited payment options, you create a tailored solution that speaks their language.

Why merchants choose custom gateways: The difference between a 2% and 5% conversion rate often comes down to payment options customers actually trust and recognize.

Still, improving conversion rates can sometimes be achieved through checkout optimization rather than adding new payment methods.

Why Regional Payment Methods Matter for Conversion

Many businesses discover that standard payment options don't match their audience's habits.

In China, customers expect Alipay. In India, Paytm dominates. European customers often prefer SEPA transfers.

A custom gateway bridges this gap by connecting these regional favorites directly to your Shopify checkout.

When Standard Payment Options Don't Work for Your Business

Some businesses operate in unique payment environments:

B2B companies might need custom invoicing systems • Subscription services require specialized recurring billing • Gaming platforms need in-game currency support

These niche requirements often can't be satisfied with standard payment providers, though businesses should first explore proven strategies to increase ecommerce sales before pursuing complex integrations.

How Custom Gateways Give You Complete Payment Control

With a custom gateway, you control the entire payment experience. You can maintain consistent branding, customize the checkout flow, and access deeper transaction data for analytics and fraud prevention.

Custom Payment Gateways: Why You Need Shopify Plus

Before going any deeper, here's the crucial caveat that stops many merchants in their tracks:

Custom payment gateway integration is exclusively available to Shopify Plus merchants.

This isn't just a pricing tier difference.

Shopify restricts this functionality because payment processing involves significant security, compliance, and support considerations that their enterprise-level support can handle.

Shopify Plus Payment Gateway Requirements and Costs

Requirement	Details	Impact
Plan	Shopify Plus only ($2,000+ monthly)	Excludes 99% of merchants
Approval	Shopify's payments team must approve your integration	Can take weeks or months
Development	Requires technical expertise or dedicated developer	$10k-50k typical cost
Compliance	PCI DSS compliance mandatory	Ongoing security audits
Revenue Share	Shopify typically takes a percentage after $150k processed	Reduces margins

The approval process alone can take weeks or months. As of 2024, Shopify's Payments Platform access is "by invitation only" while they refine their APIs.

Not on Shopify Plus?

Your options are limited to Shopify's existing payment providers or alternative solutions like manual payments (which require processing outside Shopify's checkout flow). Consider exploring Shopify Plus alternatives if you're evaluating enterprise solutions.

Custom Payment Gateway Benefits vs. Development Costs

Why Custom Payment Gateways Boost Conversion Rates

① Conversion Rate Improvements

The most compelling reason merchants pursue custom gateways is conversion optimization. When customers see payment methods they trust and regularly use, checkout completion rates can improve dramatically.

Some merchants report conversion increases of 15-30% when adding regionally preferred payment methods.

② Competitive Differentiation

Offering unique payment options sets you apart from competitors stuck with standard providers. If you're the only store in your niche accepting a specific payment method, that becomes a significant competitive advantage.

③ Data and Control

Custom integrations provide deeper access to transaction data and customer behavior insights. You can set up:

→ Specialized fraud detection → Custom reporting dashboards → Tailored customer experiences that standard gateways don't support

For comprehensive insights, consider setting up analytics tools for ecommerce success.

Common Problems with Custom Payment Gateway Development

Technical Complexity Beyond Normal Apps

Building payment integrations isn't like creating a standard Shopify app.

You're dealing with sensitive financial data, complex APIs, and strict security requirements. One small mistake can impact your ability to process payments, which directly affects revenue.

Ongoing Maintenance Burden

Payment systems require constant attention. You'll need to:

Monitor transactions for anomalies • Update integrations when APIs change • Maintain PCI compliance continuously • Handle customer payment issues and disputes through effective customer communication

Keep up with evolving regulations and security standards

Approval Gatekeeping

Even with perfect technical implementation, Shopify controls the approval process. They may require changes, reject integrations that don't meet their standards, or delay approval during heavy review periods.

How to Build a Custom Payment Gateway for Shopify (Step-by-Step)

Step 1: Planning Your Custom Payment Integration

Business Case Development

Before writing a single line of code, document exactly why you need this integration.

Shopify's payments team will want to understand:

Which payment method you're adding and why existing options don't work • Your target market and customer demographics • Expected transaction volumes and revenue projections • How this integration benefits the broader Shopify ecosystem

Technical Architecture Planning

You'll choose between two integration types:

Integration Type	How It Works	Best For
Offsite Payment Flow	Customers redirected to payment provider's site	Most custom gateways
Onsite Payment Flow	Payment details collected within Shopify checkout	Advanced integrations

Most custom gateways use the offsite approach because it reduces PCI compliance scope and is generally easier to set up securely.

Development Environment Setup

Create your development infrastructure:

→ Register for a Shopify Partner account if you don't have one → Set up a Shopify Plus development store for testing (compare this complexity with setting up checkout optimization in minutes) → Obtain API credentials and documentation from your payment provider → Prepare PCI compliance documentation and security measures

Step 2: Building the Shopify Payment App

Creating the Payment App

Using Shopify's CLI tools, you'll create a payment extension app. This involves:

# Using Shopify CLI to scaffold payment app
shopify app generate extension --type=payments

Your app will handle several key functions:

Payment Session Creation (Generate secure payment sessions with your provider) • Transaction Processing (Communicate with the payment gateway's API) • Webhook Handling (Process payment confirmations, failures, and refunds) • Error Management (Handle declined transactions and technical issues gracefully)

Security Implementation

Security isn't optional. It's the foundation of payment processing.

Key considerations:

PCI DSS Compliance

Even with Shopify handling checkout infrastructure, your app must meet PCI standards for any payment data it processes.

Data Tokenization

Never store raw payment data. Use your payment provider's tokenization system to secure sensitive information.

API Security

Set up proper authentication, use HTTPS exclusively, and validate all data exchanges with your payment provider.

Testing Strategy

Testing payment integrations requires methodical validation of every scenario (consider A/B testing strategies for optimization):

① Successful payments → Verify money is captured and orders are created ② Payment failures → Ensure graceful error handling and retry options ③ Partial payments → Test gift card combinations and split payments ④ Refund processing → Confirm refunds work through Shopify admin ⑤ Edge cases → Network timeouts, API failures, invalid data

Step 3: Getting Shopify Approval for Your Payment Gateway

Initial Application

Contact your Shopify Plus success manager or support team to begin the payments partner application.

You'll need:

Detailed integration documentation • Business information and compliance certificates

• Test store access for Shopify's review team • Technical specifications of your payment flow

Shopify's review can take 2-8 weeks depending on complexity.

Common feedback areas include:

Review Area	What They Check	Common Issues
User Experience	Smooth, intuitive payment flows	Confusing error messages
Security	PCI compliance and data handling	Missing encryption
Error Handling	Robust failure scenarios	Poor customer communication
Performance	Speed and reliability requirements	Slow API responses

Expect multiple review rounds.

Even experienced developers rarely get approval on the first submission.

Going Live

Once approved, you'll receive installation instructions for your production store. The custom gateway will appear in your Shopify admin under Settings > Payments, where you can configure and activate it.

Step 4: Monitoring Payment Performance and Success Rates

Performance Tracking

After launch, monitor these key metrics closely:

Metric	Target	Why It Matters
Payment Success Rate	>95%	Low success rates indicate technical issues
Checkout Completion	Baseline + 10-20%	Measures whether new payment method improves conversion (see checkout optimization best practices)
Customer Support Issues	<2% of transactions	Payment confusion creates support burden (streamline with automated email marketing)
Transaction Processing Time	<10 seconds	Slow payments frustrate customers

Ongoing Maintenance

Payment integrations require active maintenance:

Monthly Tasks: • Review transaction success rates and error logs • Update API credentials if they expire • Monitor payment provider announcements for changes

Quarterly Tasks: • Analyze conversion impact and ROI through marketing automation tools • Review security certificates and compliance • Update integration based on Shopify API changes

Shopify Payment Alternatives: When Custom Development Isn't Worth It

Before committing to a custom integration, consider these alternatives that might solve your problem more efficiently:

Check Shopify's 400+ Built-in Payment Gateways First

Shopify supports hundreds of payment gateways worldwide.

Many merchants assume they need custom development when an existing provider already supports their requirements.

How to Set Up Manual Payments for B2B Sales

For B2B sales or high-value transactions, manual payment methods allow customers to pay via wire transfer, check, or invoice.

While not automated, this approach works well for specific business models and can be enhanced with abandoned cart recovery strategies.

Using External Checkout Systems with Shopify

Some businesses use external checkout systems that support their required payment methods, then sync orders back to Shopify. This adds complexity but avoids custom development.

Consider simpler alternatives like QR code integration for seamless mobile checkout.

Why Checkout Optimization Often Beats Custom Payment Gateways

Sometimes the problem isn't payment methods.

It's checkout friction.

Before adding more payment options, consider optimizing your existing checkout flow.

Critical Insight: Many merchants discover that removing checkout friction delivers better conversion improvements than adding payment methods.

This is where Checkout Links becomes incredibly valuable. Instead of building complex custom payment integrations, many merchants find that removing checkout friction delivers better conversion improvements than adding payment methods.

Checkout Links creates direct-to-checkout links that skip cart pages, pre-apply discounts, and land customers directly at Shopify's optimized checkout.

Customers reach their preferred payment methods faster, without the technical complexity of custom gateway development. Plus, comprehensive analytics track performance without custom development.

Key advantages of this approach:

Works with existing payment methods → No custom development required • Immediate implementation → Set up in minutes instead of months • Reduced checkout steps → Customers go straight from product interest to purchase, enhanced with high-converting landing pages • Compatible with all Shopify plans → Not limited to Plus merchants

Built on Shopify's secure infrastructure → Inherits Shopify's payment security and compliance

Many merchants discover that reducing checkout friction provides better ROI than adding payment methods.

When customers can complete purchases in 30 seconds instead of 2-3 minutes, conversion rates often improve more dramatically than adding new payment options. This optimization also enables better customer retention strategies and upselling opportunities.

Custom Payment Gateway vs. Checkout Optimization: Which Should You Choose?

Here's a framework for deciding whether custom payment gateway integration makes sense for your business:

When Custom Payment Gateway Development Makes Sense

✅ Specific payment methods are absolutely required for your target market ✅ You're already on Shopify Plus with development resources available ✅ ROI justifies 6-12 months of development and approval time ✅ You have ongoing technical resources for maintenance and support ✅ Existing optimization efforts have been exhausted

When to Focus on Checkout Optimization Instead

✅ Cart abandonment is your primary concern ✅ Existing payment methods meet customer needs but checkout is slow (explore Shopify checkout customization options) ✅ You want immediate results without technical complexity ✅ You're not on Shopify Plus or have limited development resources ✅ Speed to market is more important than specific payment methods

Should You Build a Custom Payment Gateway? Final Recommendations

Custom payment gateway integration represents one of Shopify's most powerful but challenging capabilities. For merchants with specific regional or industry requirements, it can unlock significant growth opportunities.

Still, most checkout optimization goals can be achieved more efficiently through simplified customer journeys rather than additional payment complexity.

Before pursuing custom development, audit your current checkout experience:

→ How many steps do customers go through from product selection to purchase completion? → Are customers abandoning at payment selection or during the payment process itself? (Analyze with shopping cart abandonment solutions) → Do existing payment methods cover 90%+ of your target audience's preferences? → Would reducing checkout friction provide better conversion improvements than new payment options?

The most successful e-commerce businesses focus on eliminating friction at every step.

Whether that's through custom payment integration, checkout optimization tools like Checkout Links, or simply improving your existing checkout flow, the goal remains the same:

Get customers from interest to purchase as quickly and smoothly as possible.

Use data-driven strategies to guide your optimization decisions.

For merchants ready to tackle custom payment integration, this guide provides the roadmap. For those seeking faster conversion improvements without technical complexity, consider starting with checkout optimization strategies that work within Shopify's existing infrastructure.

Remember: The best payment solution is the one customers actually use to complete their purchases.

Either path can work.

The key is choosing the approach that aligns with your technical capabilities, timeline, and business objectives.

Custom Payment Gateway Resources and Tools

Shopify Payment Development Resources

Shopify Payments Platform Documentation • PCI Compliance Requirements • Shopify Partner Program

Checkout Optimization Tools and Guides

Checkout Links Quick Start Guide • Shopify Checkout Best Practices

Need Help Deciding?

Both custom gateway integration and checkout optimization require strategic thinking about customer experience and conversion. Consider your technical resources, timeline, and ultimate business goals when choosing your path forward.

Understanding the ecommerce customer journey helps inform the right approach.

The bottom line:

Sometimes building exactly what customers expect is the answer. Other times, it means removing every obstacle between them and the "buy now" button.