How to Send a Reminder Email That Gets Results

Do not index

OG Image

Status

Type

Ever wonder why your carefully crafted reminder emails get crickets? It's a common frustration. You hit send, feeling helpful, but your message just vanishes into the digital void, completely ignored.

So, what gives? Why are so many of these reminders dead on arrival?

Why Your Reminder Emails Are Being Ignored

Let’s be real for a second. Most reminder emails are just automated noise. They land in an already-cluttered inbox and, more often than not, get deleted without a second thought. The trick is figuring out what separates a genuinely helpful nudge from another annoying distraction. It all comes down to the psychology of how we communicate.

In a world where we’re all drowning in messages, your reminder isn’t just another email; it’s a crucial touchpoint with a customer. Get it right, and you build trust. Get it wrong, and you just create frustration and chip away at your brand's reputation.

The Psychology of the Ignore Button

The real problem is that most reminders feel totally irrelevant or don't offer any immediate value. A generic, impersonal alert comes across as a demand, but a personalized, genuinely helpful reminder feels like you're actually trying to assist them.

Think about these common mistakes—we've all seen them:

Vague Subject Lines: "Follow Up" or "Checking In" are instant skips. They tell the reader nothing and offer no reason to open.

Impersonal Tone: If your email reads like a robot wrote it, people will treat it like it's unimportant. There’s no human connection.

Lack of Clarity: Making someone dig through their inbox to find the original email for context? You've already lost.

The key is to shift your mindset from "I need you to do this" to "I'm here to help you get this done." This small change in perspective transforms the entire tone and reception of your message.

Email isn't going anywhere. Projections show it’ll hit 5.61 billion users by 2030, with billions of emails flying around every single day. The good news is that reminder emails often get higher open rates because they tap into a sense of urgency, especially since 99% of people check their email at least once a day. You can dig into more fascinating data by reviewing these insightful email statistics.

When you nail the approach, your email becomes a welcome signal, not just more noise.

Breaking Down a Reminder Email That Actually Gets Results

Ever sent a reminder that was met with total silence? It's frustrating. The truth is, a great reminder email isn't just a quick "Hey, don't forget!" It's a carefully constructed message designed to get someone to act. When you nail the key components, you turn a message that could be ignored into one that's impossible to miss.

Let's look at the anatomy of a high-impact reminder. The first battle is just getting your email opened, which all comes down to that one little line in their inbox.

As you can see, a clear and slightly urgent subject line is your best weapon for cutting through the inbox noise.

The Subject Line: Your Two-Second Audition

Your subject line is the most important part of your email. Seriously. You have about two seconds to convince a busy person to click, so vague phrases like "Follow Up" or "Quick Question" are basically digital junk mail.

A winning subject line instantly tells the reader what the email is about and why they should care right now. For instance, "Invoice Reminder" is okay, but "Heads Up: Your Invoice #1234 is Due This Friday" is so much better. It's specific, provides context, and includes a clear deadline.

A well-crafted subject line can boost open rates by over 20%. Think of it as the headline of a news article—if it isn't compelling, no one reads the story.

The right subject line depends on your goal and audience. Some styles work better than others for specific situations.

Reminder Email Subject Line Effectiveness

Subject Line Style	Example	Why It Works	Best For
Direct & Informative	Action Required: Your Cart Expires in 24 Hours	It's unambiguous and sets clear expectations.	Abandoned carts, payment reminders, formal notifications.
Personalized	Sarah, Don't Forget Your Upcoming Appointment	Using the recipient's name grabs attention instantly.	Appointment reminders, personalized follow-ups.
Benefit-Oriented	Don't Miss Out on Your 15% Discount!	Focuses on what the recipient gains by acting now.	Promotional offers, early-bird registration reminders.
Question-Based	Still thinking about the [Product Name]?	It sparks curiosity and encourages a click to find the answer.	Re-engaging customers, following up on abandoned checkouts.

Choosing the right style can make a huge difference in whether your email gets opened or ignored. The key is to match the tone to the action you want the recipient to take.

Writing a Body That's Clear and to the Point

Once they've opened your email, don't make them work for it. People scan emails, they don't read them. A huge wall of text is a one-way ticket to the trash folder.

Get straight to the point. Your opening line should be friendly but direct. Something like, "Hi [Name], this is just a quick reminder about the payment for your recent order."

From there, your email body absolutely must answer three questions:

What needs to happen? (e.g., "Please complete your checkout.")

When does it need to happen? (e.g., "Your cart and special pricing expire tonight at midnight.")

Why does it matter? (e.g., "So you don't miss out on this limited-time offer.")

Make those critical details pop. Use bold text, bullet points, or even just a simple link to draw the eye. You want to make it incredibly easy for them to know what to do next.

Finally, wrap it up with a crystal-clear call-to-action (CTA). A button or a bolded, linked phrase like "Finish Your Order Now" is far more effective than a passive sign-off. Keep the tone helpful and positive, and you'll find people are much more likely to take the action you need them to.

Nailing Your Timing and Frequency

Let’s be honest, sending a reminder at the wrong time is just as bad as not sending one at all. A payment reminder a week early feels pushy, but an appointment reminder sent 10 minutes beforehand is pretty much useless. You want to be a helpful nudge, not a nagging annoyance.

The right timing is completely situational. For things like meetings or appointments, the sweet spot is usually 24 to 48 hours beforehand. This gives people enough time to prepare or reschedule without the email getting buried in a cluttered inbox.

For other things, like a late invoice, you need a more structured approach. A gentle heads-up right on the due date is a perfect start. If you don't hear back, a slightly firmer follow-up a few days later can get the job done without souring the relationship.

Finding the Right Cadence for Different Scenarios

A one-size-fits-all approach just doesn't work. You have to tailor your reminder strategy based on what you're asking for.

Here’s what I’ve found works best:

Upcoming Appointments: A single reminder sent 24 hours prior is almost always enough. For really important meetings, I like to add a second, quick reminder about an hour before it starts.

Overdue Invoices: Kick things off with a polite email on the due date. If you still haven’t been paid, follow up 3-5 business days later with a message that's a bit more direct.

Event Reminders: A three-email sequence is golden. Send the first one a week out to build some buzz, another one the day before as a final check-in, and a last one an hour before the event begins.

Understanding when your audience is actually paying attention is the secret sauce. A well-timed email feels like a helpful service, not a demand, and that makes all the difference in getting a response.

Think about this: with over 40% of people admitting to having more than 50 unread emails, your message has to land at the perfect moment. Since 58% of consumers check their email first thing in the morning, scheduling reminders to arrive early is a savvy move.

Getting this right has a real impact. A well-timed reminder can slash missed appointments by up to 30%. You can dive deeper into these kinds of numbers in this detailed email statistics report.

Finding the Right Tone for Any Situation

Getting the tone of your reminder email right is everything. Seriously, it's the difference between a helpful nudge and an annoying demand that could sour a customer relationship for good. The trick is to stop thinking about it as a one-size-fits-all message and start matching your tone to the specific reason you're reaching out.

Take a webinar reminder, for instance. Your goal is to build excitement, so the tone should be friendly and upbeat. Something as simple as, "Hey there! Just a quick heads-up that our webinar is tomorrow," feels personal and gets them looking forward to it. It’s a low-stakes email, so warmth and enthusiasm are your best friends here.

Adjusting for Urgency and Formality

Now, flip the script to a second reminder for an overdue invoice. The friendly and casual approach won't work. You need to shift to a tone that’s professional and firm, but still polite.

A line like, "Following up on invoice #5678, which is now 15 days past due," is perfect. It's direct and factual without coming across as aggressive. It communicates the situation clearly and signals that action is needed.

Learning how to send a reminder email that adapts to different contexts is a game-changer. You want to sound like a real person, not a cold, faceless robot. This is especially true for sensitive topics, where a little empathy goes a long, long way.

Empathy is your secret weapon. Acknowledging a recipient's busy schedule with a simple phrase like, "I know things get hectic," can immediately de-escalate potential friction and make them more receptive to your request.

Think about the subtle difference in these closing lines:

Friendly Reminder (Webinar): "Can't wait to see you there!"

Firm Reminder (Invoice): "Please let us know when we can expect payment."

This kind of thoughtful adjustment shows respect for your customer while making sure your message has the intended impact. To really nail this, you might want to dive deeper into email marketing best practices that focus on building positive, long-term customer relationships.

Automating Reminders to Boost Your Efficiency

Let's be honest, manually sending every single reminder email is a huge time sink. It’s the kind of task that's easy to forget, leading to missed opportunities and lost revenue. The real game-changer here is automation. It turns that tedious daily chore into a smart system that runs itself.

Think of it less as being robotic and more as creating consistent, reliable touchpoints for your customers. You can set up workflows that fire off a reminder based on a specific event, which is far more effective than a generic blast.

Unpaid Invoices: Hook up your accounting software to send a polite nudge a day before the due date.

Upcoming Meetings: Let Google Calendar automatically email attendees 24 hours in advance.

Abandoned Carts: Have your e-commerce platform send a follow-up with a direct checkout link two hours after someone leaves.

Setting Up Smart Triggers and Delays

The magic behind all this is simple "if-then" logic. An event (the "if") triggers an action (the "then") after a delay you define. It's a fundamental concept in any good marketing automation implementation.

The biggest win here is consistency. Every customer gets the same timely, professional follow-up without you lifting a finger. That kind of reliability builds trust and makes the entire experience feel more polished.

Automated reminders almost always outperform standard campaigns. Why? Because they’re timely and directly relevant to something the customer just did. While typical email open rates sit around 24%, these triggered nudges see much higher engagement.

For more on this, our guide on https://checkoutlinks.com/blog/how-to-send-automated-emails offers a ton of detailed strategies. And with 60% of emails now read on mobile devices, these perfectly timed pings are more powerful than ever.

Here are some of the questions I get asked all the time when it comes to reminder emails. Let's break down these common sticking points so you can handle them like a pro.

How Many Reminders Should I Actually Send?

This is the classic "it depends" scenario, but I can give you some solid guideposts based on what I've seen work. There's no single magic number; it’s all about context and what you're reminding someone about.

For something like a webinar, a sequence of two or three emails usually hits the sweet spot. I like to send one out a week before, another the day before, and then a final "we're starting soon!" nudge about an hour before go-time. This approach builds a nice sense of anticipation without annoying people.

Unpaid invoices are a different beast entirely. You have to be a bit more persistent but still professional. A gentle nudge on the due date is a good start. If that doesn't work, a firmer follow-up a week later, and then a final notice after that, is a pretty standard and effective escalation.

My rule of thumb? After three unanswered reminders for the same thing, it’s time to stop. Pushing past that is just asking to get marked as spam. If it's a critical issue, pick up the phone.

Is There a Perfect Time of Day to Send a Reminder?

Forget everything you've heard about "the best time to send an email." While sending a marketing blast at 10 AM on a Tuesday might make sense, effective reminders operate on a completely different timeline.

The best time is always tied directly to the deadline or event itself.

Got a meeting tomorrow? Send the reminder the afternoon before. It gives them a heads-up to prepare without getting lost in the morning email rush.

Payment due today? Hit their inbox first thing in the morning. This gives them the entire business day to sort it out.

Always prioritize the timing relative to the event. That’s what makes your email relevant and genuinely helpful when it lands.

Do I Need to Apologize for Sending a Reminder?

Absolutely not. In fact, you shouldn't. Starting your email with "Sorry to bother you" immediately undermines your message and makes your request sound unimportant. It’s a habit we need to break.

You're sending a necessary, professional follow-up. Own it.

Instead, keep your language confident but polite. Try one of these on for size:

"Just a friendly reminder that..."

"Following up on my last email about..."

This tone feels helpful, not annoying. It frames the reminder as a standard part of doing business, which is exactly what it is.

Ready to supercharge your Shopify email workflows? With Checkout Links, you can create custom, pre-filled checkout links that recover abandoned carts and drive sales automatically. Start boosting your conversions today!