Selling on Amazon vs Shopify Which Is Better for You

Do not index

OG Image

Status

Type

Picking where to sell your products online—Amazon vs. Shopify—is one of the first major decisions you'll make as an e-commerce entrepreneur. It’s a classic fork in the road. One path drops you into a massive, ready-made market, while the other gives you the tools to build your own corner of the internet from scratch.

Choosing Your E-commerce Path: Amazon vs. Shopify

At its heart, this isn't just a platform comparison; it's a strategic choice between renting an audience and building one yourself. Think of Amazon as the world's biggest digital shopping mall. You can open a stall there and immediately have millions of shoppers walking past. Shopify, on the other hand, gives you the land and materials to build your own beautiful, standalone boutique.

This core difference really shapes everything that comes next—your costs, your branding power, how you connect with customers, and your potential for growth down the line.

Amazon’s main draw is its staggering built-in audience. As of 2025, it boasts over 300 million active buyers worldwide. For a new seller, that means instant visibility and the chance to make sales almost immediately. Shopify is the opposite; it doesn't come with any traffic. It's up to you to bring visitors to your store through marketing efforts like SEO, social media, and paid ads. If you want to dig deeper into this, foxecom.com offers some great insights.

The infographic below breaks down some of the key differences in costs and how much you can really customize your presence on each.

As you can see, the monthly subscription costs might look similar at a glance, but the real story is in the transaction fees and the level of brand control you get for your money.

Amazon vs. Shopify At a Glance

Let's boil it down. Seeing the two platforms side-by-side helps clarify their very different philosophies. One is built for high-volume sales inside a controlled environment, while the other is all about creating a unique brand that you own completely.

The crucial trade-off is between instant traffic and brand ownership. With Amazon, you tap into a ready-made market. With Shopify, you build a direct relationship with your customers, creating an asset you fully control.

This table gives a bird's-eye view of how they fundamentally differ.

Aspect	Amazon (Marketplace)	Shopify (Platform)
Business Model	Selling on a third-party platform (renting space)	Building your own branded website (owning property)
Primary Goal	Product visibility and rapid sales volume	Brand building and customer relationship management
Customer Access	Access to Amazon's existing customer base	You are responsible for attracting your own customers
Branding Control	Limited; listings must conform to Amazon's template	Complete control over store design and branding

Ultimately, there's no single "best" choice. The right platform depends entirely on your products, your goals, and how much control you want over your business's destiny.

How You Acquire and Own Your Customers

The real difference between selling on Amazon and Shopify goes much deeper than fees or features. It boils down to one fundamental question: who is your customer, and how do you reach them? The answer shapes your entire business, from your very first sale to the long-term value of your brand.

With Amazon, you get an incredible head start: immediate access to a gigantic audience that's already primed to buy. Think of it like setting up a food truck in a bustling city square right at lunchtime. You don't need to put up flyers or run ads; hungry customers are already there, wallets out.

This instant traffic is a huge boost for new businesses. The platform's immense scale, combined with the "Prime trust factor" of fast shipping and simple returns, lends your products immediate credibility. Amazon pulls in over 2 billion visits every month, a level of traffic a new store could only dream of. This exposure can fuel significant early-stage sales, as explored in this analysis of brand growth on Sumtracker.com.

Renting Customers From Amazon

But there’s a major catch to all that convenience. When you sell on Amazon, you’re essentially renting their audience. These are Amazon’s customers first and foremost, not yours. The platform acts as a strict gatekeeper, controlling communication and giving you very little direct access to customer data.

This setup is intentionally designed to keep the relationship between the buyer and Amazon, not the buyer and your brand. As a result, you can't really:

Build an email list: You are forbidden from steering customers to your own website or collecting their emails for future marketing.

Cultivate direct relationships: Your ability to follow up with customers, offer loyalty rewards, or share your brand story is severely limited.

Control the buying experience: The customer journey is standardized, leaving almost no room for unique branding or a personal touch.

On Amazon, you're a vendor in their massive department store. Your main job is to beat the competition on the next shelf over. The customer’s loyalty is to the Amazon ecosystem, not necessarily to your brand.

This model is fantastic for driving revenue quickly but falls short when it comes to building a durable business asset. Your success is completely tied to your standing within Amazon's world, which can change overnight with algorithm updates, new competitors, or sudden policy shifts.

Owning Your Audience With Shopify

Shopify is the complete opposite. Launching a Shopify store is like building your own flagship location from the ground up. At first, it’s a beautiful boutique on a quiet side street—no one knows you exist. It’s entirely on you to generate the foot traffic.

This means you have to roll up your sleeves and get serious about marketing. To attract visitors, you'll need to master a mix of strategies:

Search Engine Optimization (SEO): Getting your store to show up when people search for your products on Google.

Content Marketing: Creating useful blog posts, videos, or guides that draw in your ideal audience.

Paid Advertising: Running targeted ad campaigns on platforms like Google, Facebook, and Instagram.

Social Media Marketing: Building a community and engaging with potential customers where they spend their time.

It’s a much heavier lift in the beginning, but the payoff is enormous. Every single customer you bring in is yours. You own their contact information, their purchase history, and the direct line of communication to them.

This ownership allows you to build a truly sustainable business. You can nurture relationships, encourage repeat purchases, and dramatically increase customer lifetime value. In fact, learning how to improve this metric is key to long-term success, which you can read about in our guide on what Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) means in Shopify. With Shopify, you’re not just making sales—you’re building a brand with a loyal following that you own completely.

Building a Brand vs. Making a Quick Sale

Choosing between Amazon and Shopify isn't just a simple logistical decision. It gets to the very heart of your business philosophy: are you playing the short game for quick sales, or are you in it for the long haul to build a valuable brand? Your answer really dictates which platform makes the most sense.

Think of Amazon as a pure sales engine. It’s incredibly efficient at one thing: putting your product in front of a massive, ready-to-buy audience and converting them fast. But here's the catch—you're essentially a tenant in their massive digital mall. You get all the foot traffic, but you have to live by their rules, and the landlord's name is always above the door.

On Amazon, your main job isn't building a brand; it's optimizing a product listing. Success comes down to mastering the A9 algorithm, fighting for the Buy Box, and out-competing others on price, reviews, and how fast you can ship.

The Amazon Branding Sandbox

When you sell on Amazon, your brand identity takes a backseat to the Amazon experience. Sure, they give you some tools like A+ Content and branded storefronts, but you're working within a very rigid, pre-defined box. This is by design, as Amazon wants a consistent, predictable shopping experience for its customers.

This setup severely limits your ability to tell a compelling story or create a unique customer journey. The platform actively restricts how you communicate with buyers, making it nearly impossible to build direct relationships or market to them again outside of Amazon's ecosystem.

On Amazon, you're competing for the sale. On Shopify, you're competing for the customer. That's the fundamental difference in how you build long-term value.

At its core, Amazon helps you sell a product. It's a fantastic strategy for private label sellers, those doing retail arbitrage, or any business with standardized goods where brand loyalty isn't the primary goal.

Crafting a Brand Universe with Shopify

Shopify, on the other hand, hands you a blank canvas. It gives you the tools to build more than just a store; it lets you create an entire brand universe that you own, from top to bottom. This is where you graduate from simply moving products to creating a genuine experience.

With Shopify, you have complete creative control over your website's design, from the look of the homepage all the way to the final checkout process. This freedom allows you to build a unique brand narrative that truly connects with your ideal customer. Every visual, every word, and every interaction is yours to shape.

This level of ownership is what allows you to build a business with a real personality and cultivate a tribe of loyal fans. For anyone focused on long-term growth and customer relationships, mastering ecommerce branding strategies is absolutely essential.

Key Branding Advantages of Shopify:

Total Design Freedom: Build a store that is a true visual extension of your brand, free from the cookie-cutter templates of a marketplace.

Direct Customer Relationships: You own your customer data. This is huge. It means you can build email lists, run hyper-targeted marketing campaigns, and foster loyalty through direct conversations.

Content and Storytelling: Seamlessly integrate a blog, publish lookbooks, or use video to share your brand's mission and connect with customers on a much deeper level.

Customized User Experience: You get to choreograph the entire customer journey, from the moment they land on your site to the post-purchase follow-up, ensuring every step feels cohesive and special.

When you build on Shopify, you're building an asset. Your website, your customer list, your brand equity—it all belongs to you. This is the ideal path for niche businesses, artisan creators, and direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands where differentiation and customer lifetime value are everything. It’s a long-term play, but it’s how you turn a simple product into a powerful, sustainable brand.

Navigating Fees and Calculating True Profitability

When you’re weighing Amazon vs. Shopify, the first thing you need to get straight is the money. The two platforms couldn't be more different in how they charge you, and understanding this is the only way to figure out what you’ll actually take home.

Amazon’s model is built on a complex web of variable fees that grow with your sales volume. Think of it as paying a commission for access to their massive, ready-to-buy customer base and powerful logistics network. On the other side, Shopify gives you a more predictable, fixed-cost structure. You pay your monthly rent, and that’s that—but you're on the hook for drumming up your own customers.

Dissecting the Amazon Fee Structure

Getting a handle on Amazon’s fees can feel like peeling an onion; there are layers upon layers. The biggest slice they take is the referral fee. This is their commission on every single sale, typically falling between 8% and 15%, though some categories can see fees as high as 45%.

If you use Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)—and let's be honest, you almost have to if you want to be competitive—the costs keep coming.

FBA Fulfillment Fees: This is what you pay per unit for Amazon to pick, pack, and ship your orders. The cost changes based on your product’s size and weight.

Monthly Inventory Storage Fees: Amazon charges you for the physical space your products take up in their warehouses. These fees spike dramatically for inventory that sits for too long, penalizing slow-moving products.

Other Miscellaneous Fees: Don't forget about the smaller charges that add up, like returns processing, inventory removal fees, and the standard $39.99 monthly fee for a professional seller account.

Finally, there’s the cost that isn't technically a fee but feels like one: advertising. The Amazon marketplace is incredibly crowded. To get your products seen, you almost certainly need to invest heavily in Amazon PPC ads, a variable cost that directly impacts your bottom line.

Understanding Shopify's Predictable Costs

Shopify’s approach is much more straightforward, centered on a fixed monthly subscription. You'll find plans ranging from basic options for brand-new stores to more robust tiers for established businesses. This predictability is a huge win for anyone trying to manage a budget.

Beyond that monthly subscription, your main costs are:

Payment Processing Fees: Every time a customer pays with a credit card, there's a fee. Using the native Shopify Payments, this is typically around 2.9% + 30¢ for online transactions, with better rates available on the higher-priced plans.

App and Theme Costs: While you can get started with free themes and apps, most sellers eventually invest in premium options to get the exact look and functionality they need. These can be one-time purchases or ongoing monthly subscriptions.

Here’s the fundamental financial trade-off: With Amazon, your fixed costs are low, but your cost-per-sale is high due to transaction-based fees. With Shopify, your overhead is fixed and predictable, but you become responsible for the variable cost of bringing customers to your store.

Comparative Cost Structure Analysis

To really see how these differences play out, it helps to put them side-by-side. This table breaks down the common costs, showing you where your money goes and helping you look past the headline subscription prices.

Cost Category	Amazon Details	Shopify Details
Platform Access	$39.99/month for Professional Plan.	Starts at $29/month for Basic Plan, with higher tiers available.
Transaction Fees	Referral fees (8%-20% of sale price) per transaction.	0% if using Shopify Payments; 0.5% to 2% if using a third-party gateway.
Payment Processing	Included in referral fees; no separate charge.	Around 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction with Shopify Payments.
Fulfillment Costs	Variable FBA fees per unit plus monthly storage fees.	You handle fulfillment yourself or pay a third-party logistics (3PL) provider.
Marketing Costs	High, often necessary spend on Amazon PPC to compete.	You control your marketing budget across channels like SEO, social, and paid ads.
Customization	Limited; fees for premium brand features (A+ Content).	Potential one-time or subscription costs for premium themes and apps.

At the end of the day, true profitability depends entirely on your products and business model. If you’re selling unique, high-margin products and want to build a lasting brand, Shopify's fixed-cost model will likely be more profitable in the long run. But if you’re moving high volumes of more standardized goods, Amazon's pay-as-you-go model could be the smarter financial choice, as long as you keep a close eye on those accumulating fees.

Unlocking Growth with Data and Analytics

When we talk about Amazon versus Shopify, the discussion around data is where the two paths really fork. Honestly, data isn't just a buzzword; it’s what turns guesswork into a real, repeatable strategy. The platform you choose will determine if you get a few breadcrumbs of information or a full-course meal of actionable insights.

Amazon gives its sellers a dashboard that’s all about marketplace performance. You can track things like page views, sessions, conversion rates (what they call unit session percentage), and of course, sales. This is great for fine-tuning your listings and managing inventory on Amazon, but the information is walled off and intentionally limited.

Shopify, on the other hand, hands you the keys to the entire data kingdom. Because it's your store, it's your data. This is a massive shift in control, and its importance for brand builders can't be overstated.

The Power of Owning Your Customer Data

When you own your customer data, you get the complete picture. You’re not just seeing sales numbers; you're seeing who your customers are, what they’re buying, how they found you, and what makes them come back for more.

Shopify's built-in analytics let you dig deep into customer behavior, sales trends, and the real performance of your marketing efforts. This allows for some seriously sophisticated growth strategies that just aren't possible with Amazon's marketplace-focused metrics.

Here’s what that actually looks like in practice:

Pinpoint your VIP customers and build loyalty programs that reward them.

Calculate the true ROI of every marketing dollar, from a Facebook ad to an email campaign.

See which products fly off the shelves together and create can’t-miss bundles.

Build super-specific customer lists for personalized email and ad campaigns that actually work.

The core difference is simple: Amazon gives you data to be a better Amazon seller. Shopify gives you data to be a better business owner. This distinction is crucial for building a brand that can thrive independently.

The Limits of Rented Analytics

On Amazon, the customer ultimately belongs to them, not you. They intentionally keep direct customer contact information under wraps, which makes building any kind of lasting relationship nearly impossible. You can't just add an Amazon buyer to your email list, send them a special offer, or invite them into your brand’s community off-platform.

This creates a huge business risk. If your Amazon account gets suspended or an algorithm change buries your products, your revenue can disappear overnight. You have no direct line to the people who were just buying from you.

With Shopify, that customer list becomes your most valuable asset. It's a foundation you can build on, using that data to create powerful automated marketing funnels. If you're new to that idea, our guide on what e-commerce automation is and how it works is a great place to start.

Ultimately, the rich data from Shopify is the fuel for advanced strategies like SEO for e-commerce, which is essential for boosting sales long-term. Shopify sets you up for sustainable, data-driven growth, while Amazon keeps you focused on performing within its closed system.

So, Which Platform Is Actually Right for You?

Deciding between Amazon and Shopify isn't about finding a single "best" platform. It's about making a strategic choice that aligns with your business model, your products, and where you want to be in a few years. What works brilliantly for one seller could be a dead end for another.

To cut through the noise, let's look at this through the lens of different business types. See which of these profiles sounds most like you—it’ll point you in the right direction.

When to Go All-In on Amazon

Amazon is a sales powerhouse. It's built for speed, volume, and getting your products in front of millions of ready-to-buy customers. You should seriously consider making Amazon your primary channel if you're one of these sellers:

The High-Volume Reseller: If your game is retail arbitrage or wholesaling—buying existing products and reselling them—Amazon is your natural habitat. Here, the winning formula is all about price and availability, not crafting an elaborate brand story.

The "I Hate Logistics" Entrepreneur: For anyone who dreads the thought of packing boxes and dealing with shipping, Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) is a godsend. You ship your inventory to an Amazon warehouse, and they take care of everything else: storage, picking, packing, shipping, and even customer service. It frees you up to focus on sourcing great products.

The Market Tester: Got a new product idea? Instead of building a website from scratch, you can use Amazon's massive built-in audience to validate your concept. It’s one of the fastest ways to test demand, get early sales, and gather crucial customer feedback without a huge upfront investment.

When Shopify Is the Smarter Play

Shopify is for builders. It’s for entrepreneurs who are creating a brand, not just moving units. If control, customer relationships, and long-term asset creation are your priorities, Shopify is where you belong. This is the right choice for:

The Niche Brand Builder: Selling handcrafted goods, unique apparel, or specialized products for a passionate community? Shopify gives you a blank canvas to build a brand experience that truly connects with people. Its design flexibility is perfect for direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands that need to stand out.

The Relationship-Focused Owner: If your business relies on repeat customers and high lifetime value, you need direct access to your customer data. Shopify gives you that. Owning your customer list is a priceless asset for building loyalty through email marketing, personalized offers, and genuine community engagement.

The Multi-Channel Maverick: Are you selling across different platforms? Think social media, pop-up shops, and maybe even a brick-and-mortar store. Shopify acts as your central command center, pulling all your inventory, sales, and customer information into one place that you own and control.

The Hybrid Strategy: Using Both to Dominate

For many growing businesses, the whole "Amazon vs. Shopify" debate is the wrong way to think about it. The most sophisticated sellers don't choose one; they use both strategically.

Think of it this way: your Shopify store is your brand's flagship. It’s where you control the narrative, build direct customer relationships, and enjoy the highest profit margins.

At the same time, you can leverage Amazon FBA as a massive customer acquisition channel. Treat it like getting your product into a major retail chain. It exposes your brand to a huge audience that might never have found your website otherwise. This turns Amazon from a potential threat into a powerful tool that fuels your overall growth.

Still Have Questions? Let's Clear Things Up

Even after breaking down all the details, you might still be weighing the pros and cons of Amazon vs. Shopify. That's perfectly normal. Let's tackle some of the most common questions that pop up when you're at this crossroads.

Can I Just Sell on Both Amazon and Shopify?

You absolutely can, and frankly, it's a strategy many of the smartest brands use. Think of it this way: your Shopify store is your home base—your branded flagship where you build lasting customer relationships and keep the lion's share of your profits.

At the same time, you can treat Amazon as a massive, high-traffic acquisition channel. It’s the perfect place to get your products in front of millions of shoppers who have never heard of you. Shopify even offers integrations to help you manage inventory and orders across both platforms, making a multi-channel approach much more manageable than it sounds.

Which One Is Truly Better if I'm a Beginner on a Tight Budget?

This is where your priorities really matter. If your main goal is to build a long-term brand, Shopify is often the smarter bet for beginners. Why? Because the costs are predictable. You pay a flat monthly fee, which makes it much easier to budget for the thing that actually grows your business: marketing.

Amazon's individual plan might seem cheaper at first glance since there's no monthly subscription fee. But the reality is that the referral fees, FBA costs, and the almost unavoidable ad spend can add up fast and fluctuate wildly. For a new business trying to manage cash flow, those unpredictable expenses can be a real killer.

How Hard Is It to Move From Amazon to Shopify Later On?

"Switching" is a bit of a misleading term. It’s less of a migration and more like building a new business from the ground up. You can't just export your customer list from Amazon and import it into Shopify—you have to start building your audience all over again.

The process means creating your Shopify store, defining your brand identity, and firing up your own marketing engines like SEO, social media, and email campaigns to generate traffic. You'll also need to figure out fulfillment, either by doing it yourself or finding a reliable third-party logistics (3PL) partner. It's a major undertaking, but the payoff is complete control and ownership of your brand.

Ready to supercharge your Shopify email marketing and recover more abandoned carts? With Checkout Links, you can create powerful, personalized checkout links that integrate seamlessly with your campaigns. Drive conversions and boost your ROI without paying percentage-based fees. Start converting more customers today with Checkout Links.